Blog

Energy Conservation Opportunities (ECOs) in Cooling Tower Systems

Cooling tower systems offer significant energy savings through fan/pump optimization, water management, and intelligent control. Here are the key opportunities, categorized for clarity:

I. FAN SYSTEM OPTIMIZATION (Largest Savings Potential)

1. Variable Frequency Drives (VFDs) on Fan Motors

• Opportunity: Match fan speed precisely to cooling demand instead of on/off or 2-speed cycling.
• Savings: 30-50% of fan energy. Fan power follows the Cube Law (Power ∝ Speed³). A 20% speed reduction yields ~50% power reduction.
• Implementation: Install VFDs and control based on leaving water temperature or approach.

2. Optimize Fan Operation & Sequencing

• Opportunity: In multi-cell towers, sequence fans strategically.
• Action: Operate more cells at lower speeds rather than fewer cells at full speed (reduces parasitic losses per cell). Use the most efficient cell(s) as the “lead.”

3. High-Efficiency Fan Blades & Motors

• Opportunity: Upgrade to airfoil-shaped fan blades for better aerodynamic efficiency. Replace standard efficiency motors with NEMA Premium or IE4 class.
• Savings: 5-15% improvement in fan system efficiency.

4. Proper Fan Maintenance

• Opportunity: Ensure blades are clean, undamaged, and at correct pitch/pitch angle. Tighten belts or use direct drives to avoid transmission losses.

. PUMP SYSTEM OPTIMIZATION

5. Cooling Tower Pump VFDs

• Opportunity: Many systems run pumps at constant speed, throttling flow with valves. A VFD reduces pump speed to match required flow.
• Savings: 20-30% of pump energy (follows Pump Affinity Laws).
• Caveat: Ensure minimum flow for even distribution and prevent fill dry-out.

6. Optimize Condenser Water Delta-T (ΔT)

• Opportunity: Maintain design Range (e.g., 10°F ΔT). A “low ΔT syndrome” (e.g., 6°F instead of 10°F) forces higher water flow for the same heat rejection, increasing pump energy.
• Root Causes: Dirty chiller condenser tubes, improper control valves, or bypassing.
• Savings: Restoring design ΔT can reduce pump energy by 30-40%.

7. Parallel Pumping Optimization

• Opportunity: In multiple pump systems, optimize pump combination for part-load conditions. Often, one large pump at part load is less efficient than two smaller pumps.
• Action: Install automated controls to select the most efficient pump combination.

III. WATER MANAGEMENT & TREATMENT

8. Optimize Cycles of Concentration (COC)

• Opportunity: Increase COC to the maximum allowable by water quality.
• Savings: Reduces makeup water pump energy, water heating energy (for warm makeup), and chemical treatment costs.
• Action: Use automated bleed controllers tied to conductivity sensors.

9. Side-Stream Filtration

• Opportunity: Continuously filter a portion of the circulating water (2-10% of flow).
• Savings: Maintains clean heat transfer surfaces in the tower fill and chiller condenser, improving overall system efficiency (lower approach, better ΔT). Reduces fouling-related energy penalty.

10. Advanced Water Treatment

Opportunity: Use non-chemical or precision chemical treatment (e.g., pulsed, demand-

• based) to minimize scaling/fouling without excess chemical drag-out.
• Savings: Protects efficiency, reduces Blow down volume, and cuts chemical costs.

IV. OPERATIONAL & CONTROL STRATEGIES

11. Waterside Free Cooling (Water-Side Economizer)

• Opportunity: When ambient wet-bulb is low enough, use the cooling tower directly to produce chilled water, bypassing the chiller.
• Savings: Chiller energy drops to near-zero during suitable conditions. One of the largest ECOs in temperate climates.

12. Wet-Bulb Reset of Leaving Water Temperature

• Opportunity: Automatically reset the tower’s setpoint (cold water temp) based on ambient wet-bulb, not a fixed value.
• Mechanism: As WBT drops, allow tower to produce colder water. This lowers the chiller’s condenser temperature, improving chiller COP significantly (each 1°F drop in condenser water can improve chiller efficiency by 1-2%).
• Savings: Primarily in chiller energy, with a slight increase in fan energy.

13. Optimal Approach Control

• Opportunity: Dynamically balance fan energy against chiller energy. Find the point where fan energy increase = chiller energy savings.
• Action: Use integrated control algorithms that vary tower fan speed to maintain the most cost-effective approach, not the smallest approach.

14. Reduce Parasitic Loads & Heat Gain

• Opportunity: Insulate hot water lines to the tower and cold water lines in hot environments. Ensure sump is shaded/insulated to avoid solar heat gain.

V. MAINTENANCE & RETROFITS

15. Upgrade Fill Media

• Opportunity: Replace old splash fill with modern, high-efficiency film fill (if water quality permits).
• Savings: Improves heat transfer, allowing either reduced fan/pump energy for same duty or increased capacity in same footprint.

16. Ensure Airflow Integrity

• Opportunity: Fix leaks around access doors, seal gaps between fill bundles and walls to prevent air “short-circuiting.”
• Impact: All fan energy is used for cooling, not bypassing.

17. Eliminate Air Inlet/Outlet Obstructions

• Opportunity: Clear debris from louvers, remove nearby structures causing recirculation or interference.
• Impact: Lowers effective entering wet-bulb temperature, improving tower capacity and efficiency.

Summary: The Energy Conservation Hierarchy

Priority 1: Operational & Control Tweaks (Low/No Cost)

• Wet-bulb reset, ΔT optimization, fan/pump sequencing, COC optimization.

Priority 2: Advanced Controls & VFDs (Medium Cost, High ROI)

• Fan VFDs with approach control, pump VFDs, automated bleed, side-stream filtration.

Priority 3: Component Upgrades (Higher Cost)

• High-efficiency fans/motors, fill media replacement, waterside free cooling installation.

Priority 4: System Redesign (Major Retrofit)

• Variable primary flow, optimized pipe sizing, tower replacement.

Key Performance Metrics to Track for Energy Conservation:

1. kW/Ton of the entire chilled water system.
2. Approach Temperature (trend and vs. design).
3. Condenser Water ΔT (Range).
4. System COC and makeup water consumption.
5. Fan & Pump kWh (sub-metered).

The greatest energy savings typically come from integrating tower operation with chiller optimization (wet-bulb reset, free cooling) rather than viewing the tower in isolation.