Blog

rr 21

Cooling Tower vs. Air Cooled Heat Exchanger (ACHE)

FeatureCooling Tower SystemAir Cooled Heat Exchanger (ACHE)
Cooling PrincipleEvaporative (Wet)Sensible Heat Transfer (Dry)
Final Heat SinkAmbient Wet-Bulb TemperatureAmbient Dry-Bulb Temperature
Water UsageHighNone (Closed Loop)
MaintenanceHigh (Water Treatment, Scaling)Low (Clean Fins, Check Belts)
Initial CostHigherLower
Operating CostWater + Chemicals + Fan PowerFan Power Only
Efficiency in Hot WeatherExcellentPoor (Requires Derating)
Footprint in Engine RoomSmallLarge
Risk of LegionellaYesNo
Freeze ProtectionComplexSimple (Antifreeze)