Blog

Heat Exchanger Suitable for Cryogenics, multiple streams

The undisputed champion for this application is the Plate-Fin Heat Exchanger (PFHE), also known as a Brazed Aluminum Heat Exchanger (BAHX).

1. Brazed Aluminum Plate-Fin Heat Exchanger (BAHX/PFHE)

This is the industry standard for almost all large-scale cryogenic applications.

• How it works: Layers of corrugated fins (which form the flow passages and enhance heat transfer) are separated by flat parting sheets. These layers are stacked together, with different layers assigned to different fluid streams (e.g., natural gas, nitrogen, methane, mixed refrigerants). The entire assembly is then vacuum-brazed in a furnace to create a strong, monolithic, leak-tight core.
  
  
• Why it’s perfect for cryogenics/multiple streams:

• Unmatched Compactness & Surface Area: The finned passages provide an enormous surface area density (up to 2000 m²/m³), allowing for incredibly efficient heat transfer in a small, lightweight unit.
  • Multiple Streams: The layered design allows for the integration of many independent streams (often 5, 10, or more) into a single core. This is crucial for complex liquefaction cycles like those in LNG plants.
  • High Effectiveness: Can achieve thermal effectiveness of 95-98%, which is critical for cryogenic economics. This means the cold streams exit within just a few degrees of the warm streams entering.
  • Close Temperature Approaches: Can handle temperature approaches (pinch points) as low as 2-3°C, which is essential for efficient liquefaction.
  • Aluminum Construction: Aluminum has excellent thermal conductivity at cryogenic temperatures and high strength-to-weight ratio. It also performs well as it gets colder (it doesn’t become brittle like carbon steel).
  • Extreme Sensitivity to Fouling: The passages are small and cannot handle

• Ideal Applications:
  • LNG (Liquefied Natural Gas) Production: The absolute standard for the main cryogenic heat exchanger.
  • Air Separation Units (ASUs): For separating nitrogen, oxygen, and argon from air.
  • Helium Liquefaction:
  • Hydrogen Liquefaction and Purification:
  • Hydrocarbon Recovery (NGLs):

2. Other Suitable (but more niche) Options

While PFHEs dominate, other types are used in specific cryogenic scenarios:

Printed Circuit Heat Exchanger (PCHE)

• Why suitable: Also very compact and efficient. Can handle much higher pressures than PFHEs (over 600 bar), making them ideal for specific high-pressure cryogenic duties, such as in some hydrogen processes or for the final cooling stage.
• Drawback: Even more difficult and expensive to manufacture with multiple streams (>4 streams is very complex).

Coil-Wound Heat Exchanger (CWHE)

• How it works: A bundle of tubes is wound around a central core and enclosed in a pressure shell. Often used with a boiling refrigerant on the shell side.
• Why suitable: Robust, can handle very high pressures on the tube side and multi-phase flow on the shell side. Less susceptible to thermal stress than a PFHE.
• Application: Classic design used in many baseload LNG plants (e.g., the “Main Cryogenic Heat Exchanger” in Air Products’ C3-MR® process), often in conjunction with PFHEs.

Heat Exchanger Suitable for Cryogenics, multiple streams   The undisputed champion for this application is the Plate-Fin Heat Exchanger (PFHE), also known as a Brazed Aluminum Heat Exchanger (BAHX). 1. Brazed Aluminum Plate-Fin Heat Exchanger (BAHX/PFHE) This is the industry standard for almost all large-scale cryogenic applications. How it works: Layers of corrugated fins (which form the flow passages and enhance heat transfer) are separated by flat parting sheets. These layers are stacked together, with different layers assigned to different fluid streams (e.g., natural gas, nitrogen, methane, mixed refrigerants). The entire assembly is then vacuum-brazed in a furnace to create a strong, monolithic, leak-tight core. Why it’s perfect for cryogenics/multiple streams:Unmatched Compactness & Surface Area: The finned passages provide an enormous surface area density (up to 2000 m²/m³), allowing for incredibly efficient heat transfer in a small, lightweight unit.Multiple Streams: The layered design allows for the integration of many independent streams (often 5, 10, or more) into a single core. This is crucial for complex liquefaction cycles like those in LNG plants.High Effectiveness: Can achieve thermal effectiveness of 95-98%, which is critical for cryogenic economics. This means the cold streams exit within just a few degrees of the warm streams entering.Close Temperature Approaches: Can handle temperature approaches (pinch points) as low as 2-3°C, which is essential for efficient liquefaction.Aluminum Construction: Aluminum has excellent thermal conductivity at cryogenic temperatures and high strength-to-weight ratio. It also performs well as it gets colder (it doesn’t become brittle like carbon steel).Extreme Sensitivity to Fouling: The passages are small and cannot handle Ideal Applications:LNG (Liquefied Natural Gas) Production: The absolute standard for the main cryogenic heat exchanger.Air Separation Units (ASUs): For separating nitrogen, oxygen, and argon from air.Helium Liquefaction:Hydrogen Liquefaction and Purification:Hydrocarbon Recovery (NGLs): 2. Other Suitable (but more niche) Options While PFHEs dominate, other types are used in specific cryogenic scenarios: Printed Circuit Heat Exchanger (PCHE) Why suitable: Also very compact and efficient. Can handle much higher pressures than PFHEs (over 600 bar), making them ideal for specific high-pressure cryogenic duties, such as in some hydrogen processes or for the final cooling stage.Drawback: Even more difficult and expensive to manufacture with multiple streams (>4 streams is very complex). Coil-Wound Heat Exchanger (CWHE) How it works: A bundle of tubes is wound around a central core and enclosed in a pressure shell. Often used with a boiling refrigerant on the shell side.Why suitable: Robust, can handle very high pressures on the tube side and multi-phase flow on the shell side. Less susceptible to thermal stress than a PFHE.Application: Classic design used in many baseload LNG plants (e.g., the “Main Cryogenic Heat Exchanger” in Air Products’ C3-MR® process), often in conjunction with PFHEs.   Summary Table: Cryogenic Multi-Stream Heat Exchangers Feature Brazed Aluminum Plate-Fin (PFHE) Printed Circuit (PCHE) Coil-Wound (CWHE) Primary Advantage Multiple streams, ultra-high effectiveness, compact & light Very High Pressure capability, compact Robustness, handles multi-phase flow, high pressure Typical Stream Count High (5+) Low to Medium (2-4) Medium (2-3) Pressure Capability Moderate (up to ~100 bar) Very High (600+ bar) High (on tube side) Fouling Tolerance Very Poor (must be clean) Very Poor (must be clean) Moderate (larger passages) Relative Cost High Very High Very High Ideal Application LNG, Air Separation, Multi-stream refrigeration High-pressure H₂, CO₂, final cooling stages LNG, large-scale processes with boiling refrigerant