Film vs. Splash
| Parameter | Film Fill | Splash Fill |
| Efficiency | Very High. More surface area per unit volume allows for a more compact tower design. | Moderate to Good. Requires a larger tower volume for the same cooling duty. |
| Pressure Drop | Higher (due to more restrictive, closely spaced channels). | Lower (more open structure). |
| Fouling Tendency | High. The small, vertical channels are easily clogged by scale, silt, algae, or debris. | Low. The open structure allows solids to pass through easily. |
| Maintenance | Requires clean water and more vigilant water treatment/cleaning. | More forgiving; easier to clean manually. |
| Cost | Higher efficiency, but higher material and water treatment cost. | Lower material cost, but larger tower footprint may increase overall cost. |
| Typical Use | Power plants, HVAC, modern industrial towers with good water treatment. | Heavy industrial, wastewater, river water cooling, harsh environments. |
Critical Design & Selection Factors for Fills
- Material of Construction (MOC):
- PVC (Polyvinyl Chloride): The industry standard for film fills and splash bars. Good balance of cost, wetability, and fire resistance.
- CPVC: Used for higher temperature applications (~65-75°C vs. ~50°C for PVC).
- Polypropylene (PP): Good chemical resistance, used in specific industrial applications.
- Wood (Redwood/Fir): Traditional, still used in some lumber or harsh chemical environments. Biodegradable and can harbor microbial growth.
- Ceramic/Concrete: Used in very high-temperature specialized applications (e.g., certain metallurgical processes).
- Fill Configuration & “Flute” Size:
- Film fills come in various corrugation patterns (flutes). The angle and size of the flutes affect film distribution, surface area, and air/water contact time.
- Smaller, more tightly packed flutes = higher efficiency but higher fouling risk.
- Larger, more open flutes = lower efficiency but better fouling resistance (sometimes called “foul-resistant” or “self-cleaning” fill).
- Fill “Block” or “Sheet”:
- Fills are supplied in pre-assembled modular blocks (for easy installation/replacement) or in loose sheets that are stacked on-site (common in large FEP towers).
- Fire Safety:
- Fire-retardant (FR) PVC is almost universally required for indoor installations or near other equipment. It is designed to self-extinguish.