Blog

NCT 85

FACTORS AFFECTING COOLING TOWER PERFORMANCE

FactorEffect on PerformanceTypical Symptoms
Fouled FillIncreased approach, higher pressure dropReduced cooling, higher fan amps
Clogged NozzlesPoor water distribution, dry spots in fillUneven cooling, higher approach
Worn/Clogged Drift EliminatorsHigh static pressure, reduced airflowReduced capacity, higher fan amps
Fan Issues (loose belts, worn bearings, blade angle)Reduced airflowHigher approach, abnormal noise/vibration
Air Inlet Blockage (debris, ice)Reduced/uneven airflowReduced capacity, ice formation
Poor Water Quality (high TDS, scaling)Reduced heat transfer, increased corrosionHigh approach, visible scale, corrosion damage

PERFORMANCE TESTING & EVALUATION

Acceptance Test (ASHRAE/CTI Standards)

  • Conducted to verify the tower meets guaranteed performance.
  • Measures: Water flow rates, inlet/outlet water temps, WBT, fan power, air flow.
  • Corrects data to standard conditions for comparison.

Routine Performance Monitoring

  1. Approach trend over time (early indicator of problems).
    1. Range vs. design.
    1. Fan motor amps (indicator of air flow).
    1. Water consumption (make-up rate).

Calculating “Degradation from Design”

  • Compare current approach at design conditions (extrapolated from curves) to the original design approach.
  • >1.5–2°C increase typically indicates need for maintenance.

OPTIMIZING PERFORMANCE

  1. Load Matching: Use VFDs on fans/pumps to match part-load conditions.
  2. Water Treatment: Optimize COC and biocide programs to keep fill clean.
  3. Regular Maintenance:
    1. Inspect/clean fill annually.
    1. Clean distribution nozzles/basins.
    1. Check fan balance and alignment.
  4. Winter Operations: Use inversion controls (fan cycling, VFDs) to maintain temperature without overcooling/freezing.
  5. Upgrades: Replace old fill with high-efficiency film fill, install high-efficiency drift eliminators, upgrade to VFD fans.